A Charlie Brown Valentine is the first Peanuts cartoon special that was made after the death of creator Charles Schultz. It is also the third time that such a special was made with digital ink and paint, rather than the traditional cel-hand-drawn animation (thank you, Wikipedia.) The change in animation style also refers to the way the characters are presented on screen. They are drawn in a style that is similar to way they appeared in the newspaper comic strip. For example, you may notice the annoying white line around Lucy’s head. That is to make her appear more like she does in the comic strip. But, Schultz didn’t see a need to do it in the original specials, why do it here. It is mostly a distraction, and it was never done again.
The fact that Charles Schultz was not involved in this special is evident. The animation is not nearly as good as older Peanuts specials, and the story-line leaves much to be desired. Even so, it is a Peanuts special, and it attracted over 5 million viewers when it has been aired.
The story focuses on Charlie Brown and his secret love for the little red-haired girl. They are in the same class and despite all the effort on Charlie Brown’s part, he cannot quite find the courage to talk to her. He makes a Valentine for her and hides behind a tree, hoping that she’ll walk by and take it. In the meantime, Peppermint Patty and Marcie are both are trying to get Charlie Brown’s attention, as they are both interested. But Charlie Brown is getting his sleeve caught in the pencil sharper, trying to get the little red-haired girl’s attention.
Charlie Brown’s little sister, Sally, puts all her Valentine attention on Linus. Linus, as usual, rejects that attention and love.
Sally with hands held open: I’ll just stand here until you give me a Valentine.
Linus: Or, you can stand can like for the rest of your life and never get anything.
Linus, as usual, may be on to something. Sally has it wrong, it is not about what we get, it is about what we give. Sally makes a big deal out of the Valentine box in her classroom. I couldn’t help but wonder what would we put in Jesus’ Valentine box? I would hope that we would put ourselves in there. We are the best gift we can give Jesus. The Valentine we can give to Jesus is to show love to others.
At their wall, Linus convinces Charlie Brown that he should invite the little red-haired girl to the Valentine dance. But it doesn’t quite happen, and when Charlie Brown gets enough courage to ask her to dance, she is already dancing with Snoopy.
Charlie Brown is overly love-struck in this special. He makes reference to it himself. He gets so distracted that he cannot focus on his school work or anything else. His mind is solely on the little red-haired girl.
It is a pretty standard 25-minute special. Peanuts watchers will notice that the little red-haired girl in this special looks different than she does in It’s Your First Kiss, Charlie Brown. Here, she looks a little bit like little orphan Annie.
This Peanuts special is the 34th prime-time TV special. It first aired on February 14, 2002 on ABC, the first produced by ABC and was directed by Bill Melendez.